Papa Leo's Pizzeria Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Papa Leo's Pizzeria, where flavor and quality meet at 2265 Niagara Fls Blvd, Niagara Falls, NY. This pizzeria is a haven for lovers of classic and innovative Italian-American cuisine. The highlight of the menu is undoubtedly their pizza—crafted with sweet sauce, cup n' char pepperoni, and perfected with a tender crust that leaves patrons craving more.
Papa Leo's also offers an array of hot subs, each uniquely delicious—like the Deluxe Sub and Cheesesteak Hoagie, known for their generous fillings and flavorful toppings. Their wings are another must-try, perfectly cooked to accompany the mouthwatering pies. Customers rave about the friendly and professional service, elevating the dining experience to new heights.
Whether you’re indulging in a family gathering or a quick lunch, Papa Leo's delivers satisfying meals that keep you coming back for more!
Hot Subs
Cheeseburger Sub (12")
Stinger Sub (8")
Can't decide between steak and chicken finger? Try them both!
Bacon Cheeseburger Sub (12")
Cheesesteak Hoagie (12")
Our delicious steak with fried green peppers, fried mushrooms, and fried onion. #1 ordered sub!
Grilled Chicken Sub (8")
Bacon Cheeseburger Sub (8")
Cheesesteak Hoagie (8")
Our delicious steak with fried green peppers, fried mushrooms, and fried onion. #1 ordered sub!
Rodeo BBQ Cheeseburger (8")
Burger patties, onion rings, honey BBQ sauce... Yee haw!
Royal Sub (12")
Fried capicola and Italian sausage.
B.L.T. Sub (12")
Please specify lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Sausage Sub (8")
Sausage Sub (12")
Grilled Chicken Sub (12")
B.L.T. Sub (8")
Please specify lettuce, tomato, and onion.
Chicken Finger Sub (12")
Chicken Club Sub (8")
Chicken Finger Sub (8")
Deluxe Sub (8")
Get the best of both worlds with this Italian sausage and steak sub!
Royal Sub (8")
Fried capicola and Italian sausage.
Steak & Cheese Sub (12")
Deluxe Sub (12")
Get the best of both worlds with this Italian sausage and steak sub!
Cheeseburger Sub (8")
Chicken Club Sub (12")
Stinger Sub (12")
Can't decide between steak and chicken finger? Try them both!
Rodeo BBQ Cheeseburger (12")
Burger patties, onion rings, honey BBQ sauce... Yee haw!
Steak & Cheese Sub (8")
Finger Dinner (5)
5 fingers, your choice of sauce. Served with fries and blue cheese.
Family Feast (10)
10 fingers, your choice of sauce. Served with fries and blue cheese.
Chicken Fingers
Extras
Pizza Sauce
Teriyaki Sauce
Cocktail Sauce
Scooter Sauce
Hot Sauce
Coleslaw
Tartar Sauce
Butter Garlic
Fried Dough Sauce
Garlic Parm Sauce
Boom Boom Sauce
Salsa
BBQ Sauce
Honey Garlic Sauce
Blue Cheese
Sweet Chili Sauce
Mild Sauce
Mild.
Medium Sauce
Medium.
Honey BBQ Sauce
Ranch
Honey Mustard Sauce
Meatball Parm Pizza (XL)
Our flavorful meatballs on a red base with crushed red pepper and mozzarella!
Chicken Cordon Blue (1/2 Tray)
Ranch base with chicken, ham, Swiss, Cheddar and mozzarella? What could go wrong?
Chicken Cordon Blue (XL)
Ranch base with chicken, ham, Swiss, Cheddar and mozzarella? What could go wrong?
Chicken Finger Pizza (1/2 Tray)
Blue cheese base, with medium sauce fingers. Its a buffalo thing!
Dill Pickle Pizza (1/2 Tray)
White base pizza, with mozzarella and pickle slices. Dusted with dillweed, its the new craze!
Hawaiian Pizza (XL)
Ham and pineapple on a red base pizza, just to show everyone pineapple does belong on pizza!
Chicken Parmesan Pizza (XL)
Red sauce base with fingers and mozzarella.
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza (1/2 Tray)
White base pizza, with American cheese, fried peppers, fried mushrooms, and fried onions come standard. Fan favorite!
Meatball Parm Pizza (Medium)
Our flavorful meatballs on a red base with crushed red pepper and mozzarella!
"The Beast" (XL)
This beast has pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushroom, onion and an extra drizzle of mozzarella.
Chicken Cordon Blue (Medium)
Ranch base with chicken, ham, Swiss, Cheddar and mozzarella? What could go wrong?
Veggie Pizza (XL)
Red base pizza with tomato, onion, mushroom, black & green olives, topped with mozzarella.
Stinger Pizza (1/2 Tray)
Cant decide between steak and chicken? Try both! Blue cheese base, medium fingers.
Meat Lover's Pizza (1/2 Tray)
Red base with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon!
Meat Lover's Pizza (Medium)
Red base with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon!
Chicken Finger Pizza (Medium)
Blue cheese base, with medium sauce fingers. Its a buffalo thing!
Chicken Parmesan Pizza (1/2 Tray)
Red sauce base with fingers and mozzarella.
Chicken Finger Pizza (XL)
Blue cheese base, with medium sauce fingers. Its a buffalo thing!
"The Beast" (1/2 Tray)
This beast has pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushroom, onion and an extra drizzle of mozzarella.
Veggie Pizza (1/2 Tray)
Red base pizza with tomato, onion, mushroom, black & green olives, topped with mozzarella.
Chicken Alfredo Pizza (1/2 Tray)
Our creamy Alfredo sauce, mouthwatering grilled chicken topped with mozzarella.
Chicken Alfredo Pizza (XL)
Our creamy Alfredo sauce, mouthwatering grilled chicken topped with mozzarella.
White Pizza (Medium)
White base pizza with tomato and onions.
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza (XL)
White base pizza, with American cheese, fried peppers, fried mushrooms, and fried onions come standard. Fan favorite!
Meat Lover's Pizza (XL)
Red base with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon!
Dill Pickle Pizza (Medium)
White base pizza, with mozzarella and pickle slices. Dusted with dillweed, its the new craze!
Veggie Pizza (Medium)
Red base pizza with tomato, onion, mushroom, black & green olives, topped with mozzarella.
Stinger Pizza (Medium)
Cant decide between steak and chicken? Try both! Blue cheese base, medium fingers.
Chicken Alfredo Pizza (Medium)
Our creamy Alfredo sauce, mouthwatering grilled chicken topped with mozzarella.
Meatball Parm Pizza (1/2 Tray)
Our flavorful meatballs on a red base with crushed red pepper and mozzarella!
Stinger Pizza (XL)
Cant decide between steak and chicken? Try both! Blue cheese base, medium fingers.
Hawaiian Pizza (Medium)
Ham and pineapple on a red base pizza, just to show everyone pineapple does belong on pizza!
White Pizza (XL)
White base pizza with tomato and onions.
White Pizza (1/2 Tray)
White base pizza with tomato and onions.
Dill Pickle Pizza (XL)
White base pizza, with mozzarella and pickle slices. Dusted with dillweed, its the new craze!
"The Beast" (Medium)
This beast has pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushroom, onion and an extra drizzle of mozzarella.
Chicken Parmesan Pizza (Medium)
Red sauce base with fingers and mozzarella.
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza (Medium)
White base pizza, with American cheese, fried peppers, fried mushrooms, and fried onions come standard. Fan favorite!
Hawaiian Pizza (1/2 Tray)
Ham and pineapple on a red base pizza, just to show everyone pineapple does belong on pizza!
Specialty Pizza
Beverages
2-Liter Soda
20oz Soda
Bottled Water
Energy Drink
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onions, mozzarella cheese, chicken fingers shook in sauce of your choice.
Grilled Chicken Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, mozzarella cheese, juicy grilled strips of chicken breast.
Garden Salad
Lettuce, sliced tomatoes, diced onion, topped with fresh mozzarella.
Taco Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, hot peppers, black olives, with fresh mozzarella and hot taco meat, served with sour cream and med sauce on the side.
Antipasto
Lettuce, tomato, onion, sliced hot peppers, sliced black olives, fresh mozzarella cheese, freshly sliced salami and pepperoni.
Julienne Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, fresh mozzarella, freshly sliced ham and turkey.
Salads
Munchies
Chips
Onion Rings
Served with boom boom sauce.
French Fries
Served with ketchup.
Pizza Logs
Served with marinara sauce.
Mozzarella Stix
Served with marinara sauce.
Buffalo Fries
French fries tossed in hot sauce, served with blue cheese.
Deep-Fried Mushrooms
Served with blue cheese.
Fried Pickles
Served with ranch.
Jalapeño Poppers
Served with sour cream.
Cheddar Bacon Fries
Served with ranch dressing.
Cajun French Fries
Served with ranch dressing.
XL Chicken Finger
Blue cheese base, with medium sauce fingers. Its a Buffalo thing!
Topping Galore
12" Turkey Sub
Monthly Specials
Jumbo Buffalo Wings
10 Wings
80 Wings
30 Wings
20 Wings
50 Wings
Breaded Shrimp
Our honey-battered shrimp, served with cocktail sauce and served with fries.
Fish Fry
Our 16 oz battered haddock with tartar, served with fries and coleslaw.
Seafood
Traditional Pizza
2 Slices & Pop
X-Large
16" 8 slice pie.
1/2 Tray Pizza
15 slice half-tray pizza.
Party Pizza
30 slice tray (2x half trays).
Slice
Med Pizza
12" 6 slice pie.
Baked Cheese Sub
Oven-baked sub with multiple cheeses of your choice!
Tuna Melt Sub
Tuna sub, but oven-baked!
Pizza Sub (8")
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Red sauce and fingers, topped with mozzarella and baked golden.
Pizza Sub (12")
Meatball Parmesan Sub
Red sauce and meatballs, topped with mozzarella and baked golden.
Oven-Baked Subs
Deli Subs
Salami Sub (12")
Veggie Sub (8")
Your choice of lettuce, tomato, and onion. Comes with black and green olives as well.
Capicola Sub (8")
Tuna Sub (12")
Ham Sub (12")
Veggie Sub (12")
Your choice of lettuce, tomato, and onion. Comes with black and green olives as well.
Assorted Sub (12")
Capicola, bologna, and salami.
Bologna Sub (8")
Turkey Club Sub (12")
The Alexander (12")
Capicola and turkey, with a light drizzle of hot sauce.
Tuna Sub (8")
Assorted Sub (8")
Capicola, bologna, and salami.
Salami Sub (8")
Capicola Sub (12")
Ham & Turkey Sub (8")
Ham & Turkey Sub (12")
Ham Sub (8")
Bologna Sub (12")
The Alexander (8")
Capicola and turkey, with a light drizzle of hot sauce.
Turkey Club Sub (8")
Hamburger
Keeping it simple? Can't go wrong with our mouthwatering hamburgers. Served with fries.
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Angus burger served with sautéed mushrooms covered in melted Swiss cheese on our fresh Costanzo's kaiser rolls. Served with fries.
Rodeo Burger
Let's take it out west. Angus burger served with 2 onion rings and doused in mouth watering tangy honey BBQ sauce. So good! Served with fries.
Cheeseburger
Your standard delicious cheeseburger with melted white American. Served with fries.
Pickle Ranch Burger
Angus burger served with pickle slices and deep-fried pickle chips coated in ranch dressing. So good! Served with fries.
Burgers
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread
Served with marinara.
Garlic Bread With Jalapeño & Bacon
Served with marinara.
Garlic Bread With Cheese
Served with marinara.
Garlic Bread With Cheese & Sausage
Served with marinara.
Chicken Parm Burrito
Steak Burrito
Beef Burrito
Stinger Burrito
Steak and fingers with your choice of sauce.
Chicken Fajita Burrito
Comes with fried onions and green peppers.
Chicken Finger Burrito
Veggie Burrito
Grilled Chicken Burrito
Philly Cheesesteak Burrito
Steak, fried mushroom, fried onion, fried green peppers.
Burritos
Quesadillas
Grilled Chicken Quesadilla
Served with salsa and sour cream. Comes with light onion.
Steak Quesadilla
Served with salsa and sour cream. Comes with light onion.
Cheese Quesadilla
Served with salsa and sour cream. Comes with light onion.
Beef Quesadilla
Served with salsa and sour cream. Comes with light onion.
Breadsticks (12)
Served with 2 sides of marinara.
Fried Dough Sticks (12)
Served with 2 sides of dessert sauce.
Breadsticks (6)
Served with 1 side of marinara.
Fried Dough Sticks (6)
Served with 1 dessert sauce.